Talk:Mothra

Why is Mothra here?
Mothra is not an alien in any sort of way. I'm Titanollante...Roar to me and I'll roar back. 18:00, June 10, 2014 (UTC)


 * This sort of thing has been discussed many many times on the wiki and it seems we never did get a clear and comprehensive policy about the subject: what kinds of non-extraterrestrial beings are acceptable here? Because like you said, Mothra is definitely not extraterrestrial, she is an Earth guardian created by the very life force of the planet Earth (or at least that's what the Shobijins believe, but it seems to be so). On the other hand, we have covered other elements of the Godzilla mythology, so personally, I see no problem in having Mothra here. Although she isn't an alien, she is part of a larger fictional universe that does include aliens, and is an important element of said universe; not to mention that she has battled aliens, such as King Ghidorah. But as I said, that is my opinion. We should try to reach an agreement between all admins and active users and create some kind of policy that covers these cases rather than trying to sort out every individual case as we go along... -- BlueFrackle (talk) 18:44, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
 * Okay, well, why don't we have a Godzilla page then? How can Mothra be here but not Godzilla? I'm Titanollante...Roar to me and I'll roar back.  18:52, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
 * As far as I'm concerned, we could have Godzilla here too. But as I already said: my word is not the law, we should discuss it with the other admins and see what they think. If it is agreed that Mothra is OK, then we should definitely write a page for Godzilla as well. -- BlueFrackle (talk) 18:57, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
 * ...Non-alien Creatures Wiki already has these guys, aren't those guys supposed to cover non-alien creatures the way this one isn't? I'm Titanollante...Roar to me and I'll roar back.  19:02, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
 * I know it has, I was the one who wrote the Mothra page for Non-Alien Creatures Wiki. But there are some creatures covered on both wikis, for example, the Sleestak, Morlocks, or the Silurians. -- BlueFrackle (talk) 19:18, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
 * We should hold that discussion or something and reach an agreement soon. I'm Titanollante...Roar to me and I'll roar back.  20:16, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

Although I personally dont think that every godzilla Kaiju needs to be here (such as the Dragma) I do feel that Mothra belongs, considering the nature of Batra and the fact that she once flew into space to prevent a meteor strike... the character has had direct contact and involvement in extraterrestrial events. Mothra is one of the more grey-area pages here I think. ralok (talk) 01:39, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

I apologise for the issues I've caused with creating this page. I assumed that, since there's been humans on here who have had dealings with aliens (such as Elizabeth Shaw and Ellen Ripley), Mothra would be a suitable entry following her fighting against alien threats (such as Gigan, King Ghidorah and Monster X). - DeltaSquad5