Talk:Batreaux

It Cannot Be Both...
So, if he's in Skyward Sword as clearly shown in the screenshots, he obviously isn't in Men In Black, then, is he? MiB is by Malibu Comics, LoZ is by Nintendo of Japan (and only by extension, Nintendos of America & Europe). Therefore, this belongs on our sister wiki, not here. Not only this, but as a character he is not of the alien species of "Batreaux", and thereby wouldn't belong in the gallery under that name. I'll move him myself if I have to tomorrow, but tonight calls for some Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary marathoning (that last link is a bit of an obscure joke...get it?). Plus, by waiting a day, I'm giving people a chance to dispute this move or explain exactly how it makes sense. -- Somarinoa 10:14, November 15, 2011 (UTC)


 * He used to be a bad alien 14 years ago. Although i could tell he is an alien because he has slime in his body. He was until he started to be a good one but the fanon wiki is for fanon stuff. This creature is not a fan alien. Its a real Batreaux so this isn't fan-made alien.--TricklesTest 22:54, November 15, 2011 (UTC)


 * Fanon refers to anything a fan of a series creates, even if it is about an existing character. For instance, there are thousands at least fanon stories involving the various captains in Star Trek, such as Captain Kirk and Captain Jean-Luc Picard being major ones.  Even though the characters are official, all of those stories are what is called fanon.  Another instance on my own regard is my page for Dark Link on Zelda Fanon Wiki - while Dark Link is an existing 'character', my personal information I thought up about him is fanon.  For the record, slime is not an immediate indication of an alien species - it can also indicate a monster (which are not necessarily extraterrestrial, even if they're alien in the sense of being foreign).  At the same time, not all demons are aliens either, depending on how the media source in question chooses to treat them.  For instance, the Daemons in Warhammer 40k are aliens, but the devil in his portrayal in...oh, let's say 1997's The Devil's Advocate is never referred to as extraterrestrial being. -- Somarinoa 21:42, January 30, 2012 (UTC)


 * Is this some kind of joke?


 * The article demon could be on the alien species gallery so i would suggest an article about Demons.--TricklesTest 17:04, December 24, 2011 (UTC)


 * Lol fandom fandom fandom
 * the character IS real as we know it is in Zelda Skyward sword
 * but his story is a WHOLE LOT different from this piece of...
 * His first apearance is in Skyward sword wich he has been turned into a DEMON!!
 * not an alien, A FREAKING DEMON.
 * and dont get me started on that slime in the body thing :O!
 * its just a freaking demon he has no slime in his body!!
 * this fandom has to stop at once -_-

Status Confirmation
While I'm a huge fan of The Legend of Zelda series, I don't own a Wii. Can anyone confirm his having come from space or anything at all? Aliens do appear to exist in the LoZ series ("They" in Majora's Mask are likely aliens, and the Deities could be considered ones too, I suppose, considering Warcraft's Titans are pretty much in the same position), but that doesn't mean most species or characters are aliens, since it's never been stated directly that the Zelda universe takes place on its own planet, nor has a planetary map ever shown that it is not some form of Earth. If Batreaux is never stated as having "come from beyond the sky" or similar, then he'd likely fit on Non-Alien Species Wiki instead of here. -- Somarinoa 21:42, January 30, 2012 (UTC)


 * Possibly for that. He can fit in the alien species wiki because demons are aliens. I know there are articles for some of the demons. For that i removed the misleading/false info about that character. And hes an alien demon character of skyward sword. I played it before but hes undefeatable in that game.Diddy 05:22, March 2, 2012 (UTC)


 * That's not precisely true. Not all demons are considered aliens here, only those who appear on some planet other than Earth (such as those in the DooM series), or ones specifically considered aliens like those in the Warhammer universe(s) count - or at least, are supposed to.  Also ones specifically stated as coming from an alternate reality (similar to how the Rikti and that one race from Sliders could be considered aliens), and those in the Bible since there are theorists who consider them possible aliens.


 * However, the devil in, say, Paradise Lost or The Devil's Advocate don't count, since they're treated as the typical idea of a devil/demon in mythology and not aliens. InuYasha also wouldn't count as he is supposed to be a Japanese demon, which were also considered a species from Earth...at least, as far as I know about Japanese mythology.  That being said, I am still not 100% certain as to where Hyrule takes place.  It obviously isn't Earth and its alternate reality plane, Termina, has a moon very obviously not Luna.  Guess we'll never know for certain until Fox McCloud crashlands on Hyrule...though Arwings did appear as (deleted) enemies in Ocarina of Time, so maybe they're all just ridiculously massive giants and he already did crash there.  Ah well. -- Somarinoa 14:38, March 28, 2012 (UTC)